January 20, 2025

Asphalt Shingles vs Metal: Which Roof Material Do Local Roofing Contractors Recommend?

Author

Update First Last in Content -> Business Text -> First Last field

Date

January 20, 2025

Share

When it comes to choosing a roofing material for your home, you may need to decide between asphalt shingles and metal roofs. Each has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, and the choice often depends on factors such as budget, climate, and personal preference. In this blog, we will take a detailed look at both asphalt shingles and metal roofing to help homeowners make an informed decision.

Durability and Longevity

Durability is a critical factor when selecting a roofing material. According to Architectural Digest, homeowners can expect an asphalt shingle roof to last about 15 years before needing replacement. This lifespan can vary depending on the quality of the shingles and the environmental conditions in your area.

In contrast, metal roofs are known for their exceptional longevity. In our experience, a properly installed metal roof can last 40 to 70 years, depending on the material and maintenance. This makes metal a standout choice for homeowners seeking a long-term investment. Local roofing contractors often recommend metal roofs for areas prone to extreme weather conditions, as they are resistant to wind, hail, and fire.

Aesthetic Appeal

The appearance of your roof plays a significant role in the overall curb appeal of your home. Asphalt shingles are available in a wide variety of colors and styles, making them a versatile choice for different architectural designs. They can mimic the look of higher-end materials like slate or wood, providing an upscale appearance without the high price tag.

Metal roofs also offer diverse aesthetic options. They come in various finishes, colors, and profiles, allowing homeowners to achieve a sleek, modern look or a traditional style. However, some homeowners may find the industrial appearance of metal less appealing than the classic look of asphalt shingles. This is simply a matter of personal style and taste.

Environmental Impact

For environmentally aware homeowners, the environmental impact of roofing materials is an important consideration. Asphalt shingles are less environmentally friendly, as they are made from petroleum products and may end up in landfills when replaced. For those homeowners making eco-friendly choices in other areas, the other aspects of asphalt shingles may outweigh their environmental impact.

Metal roofs, on the other hand, are highly recyclable and can be made from recycled materials. Their energy efficiency is another advantage; in our experience, metal roofs reflect solar heat, reducing cooling costs in warmer climates. Local roofing contractors often recommend metal roofs for homeowners looking to minimize their carbon footprint and save on energy bills.

Installation and Maintenance

Asphalt shingles are easier and quicker to install, which can be a significant advantage for homeowners seeking a fast turnaround. They are also relatively simple to repair, making them a convenient option for many. The convenience of maintaining asphalt shingles is attractive, as this maintenance can help extend the lifespan of the roof.

Metal roofs require specialized installation techniques, which can make the process more time-consuming and costly. However, their durability means they require less maintenance over time. Local roofing contractors note that while the initial installation of a metal roof may be more complex, the reduced need for repairs can be a worthwhile trade-off.

Recommendation of Roofing Contractors

Ultimately, the choice between asphalt shingles and metal roofs depends on your specific needs and priorities. Local roofing contractors often recommend asphalt shingles for homeowners looking for an affordable, easy-to-install option with decent durability. This makes asphalt an excellent choice for those on a budget or for homeowners who are planning to sell their homes soon.

For homeowners seeking a long-term solution with superior durability and energy efficiency, local roofing contractors frequently suggest metal roofs. While the upfront cost is higher, the long lifespan, low maintenance, and environmental benefits make metal an appealing investment for many. The industrial appearance of metal roofing is also a selling point for many individuals.

Both asphalt shingles and metal roofs have their merits. Consulting with local roofing contractors can provide valuable insights tailored to your home and region. By weighing the pros and cons of each material, you can make a choice that aligns with your budget, style, and long-term goals. For more information about which roofing option may be right for you, contact our team at Bates Roofing. Our experienced professionals are ready to help with all your roofing needs.

local roofers
July 1, 2026
Learn how local roofers trace hidden water intrusion, identify roof leaks early, and help protect your home from costly damage before problems worsen.
June 30, 2026
Get a detailed estimate from a trusted roofing company. Ensure absolute transparency with a clear scope of work, material warranties, and zero hidden costs.
local roofers
June 17, 2026
Let's discuss common signs of roof damage that homeowners can often identify from the ground and explain when it's time to contact professional local roofers.
April 14, 2026
Bates Roofing Transforms Laekwold Gardens Wedding Venue with new wood shake roof
Two-story light blue house with dark roof and green bushes in front on a grassy lawn under cloudy sky.
October 8, 2025
Another 2025 ReRoof Transformation In Tacoma, WA
Brown cedar shake roof, under construction, with a backdrop of green trees and blue sky.
August 8, 2025
Check it out! We do tons of asphalt composition shingles but we also do alot of specialty roofing products. Keep an eye out for some of our metal, DaVinchi Roof Scapes and flat roofing job features coming up! On this particular project we were completing a reroof on a commercial building. You can see from the before photos that the existing wood shake roof was rotten and past it's useful life. With over 40 years in business installing roofs as one of Washington States longest standing roofing contractors, we were the best choice for this business owner. We tore off the existing roof and addrssed all structural issues to ensure the new roof had a solid foundation. Our team of expert roofing technicians installed a brand new cedar shake roofing system according to manufacturer specifications. It looks amazing! Hats off to our fantastic crew. Check out the job photos below!
Green corrugated metal roof with white-framed windows on a building.
July 22, 2025
Discover the long-term benefits of metal roofing, including durability, energy savings, and weather resistance, for homeowners seeking a lasting solution.
Blue house with a three-car garage. Wet driveway, trees in the background. Two blue trash bins.
July 10, 2025
We love transforming homes with new roofing systems. Recently we had the opportunity to help give a Puyallup home a facelift with a CertainTeed Presidential TL asphalt roofing shingle. This particular home had an existing wood shake roof on it that was worn and past its useful life. Wood shakes are typically installed on skip sheathing, which consists of boards with spaces in between. You can see that clearly in the pictures below. New roofing systems need a solid roof deck to be installed on in order to meet manufacturer requirements. After tearing off this roof our first order of business was to install a new solid roof deck with 1/2 CDX plywood. Next we apply our synthetic underlayment, ice and water shield, sheet metal flashings, pipe boots vents and shingles. The CertainTeed Presidential TL shingles are the standard for premium designer shingles. They are super heavy weight, thick and are designed to have a authentic wood shake look. This particular homeowner chose charcoal black, which is one of the most popular colors. This roof boasts a 50 year limited lifetime warranty and with our Select Shingle Master warranty certification a 25 year workmanship. If you are interested in transforming your home with a new shingle system from the top roofing contractor in the Puget Sound call us today!
Rows of sand stretching to the horizon, dotted with dark lines, under a bright blue sky.
June 23, 2025
Are you interested in why more homeowners are choosing metal roofing services? Look no further! Read this article or give us a call today to learn more.
House under construction, driveway, trucks. Partial roof removed, debris on blue tarp. Cloudy day.
May 30, 2025
When it comes to the integrity of a roofing system, there is more to it than meets the eye! Everything in the building and structural world starts with the foundation. When the foundation is set correctly everything else can be constructed properly. If the foundation is off it affects the rest of the project very much like an airplane that starts 1" off course at the beginning of the flight but ends up miles off from its destination. Its no different on an asphalt roofing system. Even though you don't see the roof deck it's a critical component. It's crucial that your roofing contractor carefully inspects your roof deck to look for any potential rot, water damage, mold or brittle areas. Improperly ventilated homes can contain alot of moisture which can create an atmosphere for attic mold, which is extremely hazardous for your health. If the underside of your decking is full of attic mold all or some of the plywood needs to be replaced. Failed shingles, high or low nail placement, broken vents or pipe boots among other issues can cause roof leaks and water intrusion. Consistent water intrusion creates rot. The fasteners for the new shingle system will not hold in soft or rotten plywood. This can create premature failure and shingle blow off in moderate or high winds. Car decking roof decks can also present a problem. While they technically meet manufacturer codes the older wood is often extremely dry and brittle and does not hold fasteners. At Bates Roofing we utilize the best practice approach in every aspect of our business. All plywood is inspected and compromised plywood is removed and replaced to create a smooth solid substrate. A smooth substrate is also important as large variations in the plywood placement will telegraph through the asphalt shingles over time and give a new roof an ugly appearance. We are a safe choice for your roof replacement because we don't cut corners! We meet the highest level of Washington State codes, NRCA requirements and manufacturer expectations for upgraded system warranties. Below are some "found in the field" examples of replacing bad plywood during a reroof job. Thank you for choosing Bates Roofing as your local roofing contractor.
Show More